Difference between revisions of "LAH Wiki:Dispute resolution"
From LAH Wiki
(Organizational issues) |
|||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
==Disputes== | ==Disputes== | ||
| − | + | * Organization of lolikon media --[[User:Louslet|Louslet]] 07:05, 7 October 2007 (PDT) | |
| + | :SAT asked in the [[Talk:otakubeam]] whether we should give the two parts of [[[And_hand_tied]] their own articles. We don't yet have a policy on how to organize doujinshi/manga/compilations. This could be a problem when the wiki gets bigger. | ||
| + | :As I see it there are four categories to consider. | ||
| + | ::'''(1)''' Standalone publications (eg ''Ai? Tsumi wa doko?'') | ||
| + | ::'''(2)''' Series that follow one story (eg ''And_hand_tied'') | ||
| + | ::'''(3)''' Compilations (eg ''Life is Peachy'') | ||
| + | ::'''(4)''' Series of standalone compilations (eg ''Comic LO'') | ||
| + | |||
| + | :A '''(1)''' doujin/manga should obviously have its own articles. The others are sticky. | ||
| + | |||
| + | :I say (4) should be organized with a tree pattern. There should be a main article titled after the series (eg ''Comic LO'') that has links to articles for each individual issue (eg ''Comic LO 1'', Comic LO 2''). These articles should be handled like (3) articles. | ||
| + | |||
| + | :(3), compilations, should have their own articles. These articles should include a table listing the segments or "chapters" inside the issue. There should not be an article for each segment in a compilation: there's not enough data and it would create an organizational nightmare. | ||
| + | |||
| + | :(2) is the matter that brought up the debate. There are benefits in both separating and combining. However, I personally think a series should have just one article. For example, look at ''Kodomo no Jikan''. Does it make sense to have an article for each volume? The story flows together, so dividing the series article seems pointless. | ||
| + | |||
| + | :Whatever we decide, we should create an article on this wiki's standards. It should be flexible, but it should exist. Or else the archives we create could start resembling mazes. | ||
{{LAH}} | {{LAH}} | ||
